Our clients rely on us, return to us and refer us.

Valerie N.

"I have so many positive things to say about my experience with Maywright and Natalie Clayton -- I hardly know where to start! Natalie has been a true partner on our real estate journey, providing value, wisdom, resources at every turn. And she's a pure delight to work with, so every text, visit, phone call was a welcomed interaction. Natalie consulted on some home improvements we were considering over a year before we listed. We wanted to ensure they were choices that would provide a strong ROI. She gave sound advice that we used to prioritize projects. When it was time to list, we were debating delaying listing our home given the market trends. She shared informed projections, and walked us through the possibilities so we could determine what made the most sense for us. We ended up listing at the latest date we had calculated out, and actually sold the home for slightly more than what she describe as the highest-end projection. She curates an incredible community of talented, kind people and brings them in to support you in the process as needed. From breathtaking photography, to immaculate staging, and introducing us to a mortgage lender whose rates and customer service far exceeded what we thought possible, we were always pleasantly surprised. She also represented us on a new build. We'd picked the neighborhood prior to working with her because it's proximity to personal interests was ideal for us. We didn't realize that the realtor's commission on a new build comes from the builder and was no expense to us, or else we would have reached out to her immediately! And we're so glad she represented us. She helped us do a little more research to confirm this neighborhood was our best option, which gave us peace of mind knowing we were making the right choice. And in this age of supply/demand issues, constant delays, and worker shortages, there were many, many pain points with the builder. She always represented us well, had our back, thought to ask questions we hadn't considered to mitigate the pain points. I can't imagine going through this process without her. While all of this would make me hire Natalie again in a heartbreak, what stands out to me most is what an incredible human she is. She is gracious, patient, kind, responsive, proactive. So many things that make me cherish every interaction. Thank you, Natalie, for making our home buying experience not only positive, but an intentional and informed financial strategy."

Home Buyer

"Carissa Hawkins was such a great REALTOR® to work with! She handled every detail of both of our transactions with professionalism and integrity. She did so much behind the scenes so I didn't have to worry about a thing. I recommend using Carissa for all of your house buying and selling needs!"

Cari E.

"Chanda and everyone at Maywright were absolutely amazing to work with. We were first time homebuyers in a highly competitive market and Chanda was so great answering our many questions, identifying the style and features of the house we wanted, and helping us create a winning offer."

Jessie S.

"I am so grateful I had Jess to help with the process of finding and buying the perfect home and then selling mine! She had a solution for any challenge that came up in the process. She also listened and armed us with knowledge to make good choices, rather than pressure us or tell us exactly what to do. She was completely spot on with her knowledge of the market. With regards to getting my house ready to sell, she gave great advice and used her designer eye and amazing photographer to make my house show better than I ever thought possible. I feel confident there is absolutley no better real estate team in Indy than at Maywright! I hope not to move again for a long time, but after my experience, they will definitely have my business for life."

Home Seller

"Diane Freeman is the best REALTOR® we’ve ever used! We have owned 6 homes in 4 states, so we are a bit experienced with the process. She listed/sold our suburban home and helped us find/purchase our city condo. She is knowledgeable, easy to work with, responsive, patient and thorough. She went above and beyond our expectations!"


"I am a small business owner that builds new houses in Indianapolis, and I completely trust Jess Martin to price and sell my projects. I also feel very comfortable and confident coming to her with design advice, tricky layout adjustments, architectural questions, etc. An excellent leader with a wonderful creative mind. Highly recommended."

Andrea L.

"We enjoyed working with Ross Bemis! He helped us find the perfect home for us and sold our house very quickly. We appreciated his honest opinions and knowledge of potential older home issues. He was also a great resource in helping to decipher our inspection reports on both homes. We would highly recommend hiring Ross!"

Hannah C.

"A friend referred me to Maywright when I was looking for my first home. I knew nothing about buying a house, but Kyle is a wonderful agent who walked me through everything I needed to know. The housing market in March/April 2022 was incredibly competitive and very stressful, but Kyle was very flexible to look at just-posted listings and make time when I needed it. When our offer was accepted, Kyle did a great job of building rapport with the seller and communicating on my behalf. I'm very happy I went through Maywright and bought my first house!"

Jake B.

"I was a first-time homebuyer and was fortunate enough to have friends highly recommend Murphy Hendy at Maywright Properties Co. He was an amazing REALTOR® and purchasing my first home could not have gone more smooth all because of his communication skills and empathy. I would share things he did and friends and family would always comment, "wow! Your REALTOR® is great!" He truly was. The professionalism and assistance he and Maywright leveraged just can't be beat. I couldn't recommend them enough."

Autumn M.

"I worked with agent Ross Bemis to buy my first home. He worked diligently to negotiate a deal that I felt comfortable with on my home. He had great communication throughout the entire process, and Maywright in general did a great job. I would recommend working with him and Maywright!"

Demarise A.

"I had been in the house buying process for nearly two years with no luck. When Kyle heard my story, he made my house search his top priority and I had an accepted offer and signed purchase agreement in less than a week. He is so knowledgeable and an amazing communicator and negotiator. I would recommend him in a heartbeat to anyone."

Home Seller

"Elizza was fantastic! She was very responsive to any issues we had, anticipated and handled things that made it clear she knew exactly what she was doing. We really appreciated her knowledge, professionalism, and experience. Following her advice and suggestions allowed us to get a fantastic result in selling our home."

Noah D.

"Had a great experience with agent Ross Bemis, who helped me find a house in no time. His expertise was much needed, as I had never gone through the home buying process before. Ross was intelligent, willing to answer calls at any time of day, and knew the market backwards and forwards. Would highly recommend Maywright for a first time home buyer or an experienced one. They know their stuff!"

Home Seller

"We listed and sold our townhome in downtown Indianapolis working with Diane Freeman from Maywright. Diane was a fantastic support to us throughout the listing, showing and sales process. We could not have asked for a better resource for sound advice and encouragement. We highly recommend both Diane and Maywright."

Ashleigh D.

"Lesli was amazing to work with. She truly went above and beyond to help us find our dream home. She was extremely easy to work with and very flexible. She even helped my husband check out the house when I was unable to see it. We would highly recommend her to anyone wanting to buy or sell their home!"

Amber S.

"Natalie and her team provided the most seamless experience in selling my home. All my questions were answered and concerns addressed quickly, so I could focus on my move and not on all of the behind-the-scenes processes and challenges that come with selling your home. From staging to closing, Natalie and team were there every step of the way, keeping me informed and calm (ha!) and ensuring I had everything I needed to understand tradeoffs and make decisions. I couldn’t have been happier with how it all worked out, and am delighted that my first home was in the best hands."

Home Buyer

"Literally the best part of this whole experience was Elizza. I had so much fun just talking to her it hardly felt like a chore to house hunt. I learned so much and got so much out of this whole thing I would absolutely go through her again. I'm going to suggest Elizza to everyone I know looking for a house."

Home Seller

"We worked with Tatiana and Elizza, HIGHLY recommend both. Both were extremely knowledgeable about the market, responsive to any concerns we had through the process and anticipated potential issues ahead of time which saved us time, money, and stress. They had a few great suggestions which got us a great price in selling our home. 100% would go with Maywright again."

Karlie B.

"We love the Maywright team! Ally went above and beyond to find us a house that we absolutely love in the perfect neighborhood. She is so easy to work with and incredibly responsive. We were living out of state at the time we took possession and Ally went above and beyond to ensure everything was taken care of until we were able to arrive in person. She is SUCH a gem and I would recommend working with her any day. We also loved working with Mar on the technical side of the house, she is so warm and easy to work with. She even spent time sitting on a call with me to ensure I felt comfortable doing some paperwork to-do's that were new to us. Thank you Maywright team, you're a dream and I loved our experience working with you. We will be loyal to you all forever!"

Home Buyer

"As a first time home buyer I knew nothing about the process. Danielle walked me through everything & explained the whole process in a way that was easy to understand. Danielle worked to show me all of my options until we found the perfect one. I’m in love with my home! I seriously don’t know how I would have gone through the process without her! She made it feel easy, enjoyable, and stress free! I would recommend Danielle to anyone!"

Rachel D.

"Maywright provides all the resources you need to buying a home every step of the way, especially speaking as a first-time home buyer. Everything is laid out in a clear manner for anyone to understand the many steps to getting a home and all that comes with it. Sydney Mills was fantastic to work with, her availability was super flexible with our busy work schedule and shew was quick t o respond to any requests, showings, or questions that came up. She really knows what to look out for and had our best interest in mind throughout the house-hunting process. Throughout the pending process - with inspections, negotiations, and repair estimates - we trusted her input and she coordinated with others in quick time for us. We truly have her and Maywright to thank for landing such a beautiful home that perfectly fits our lifestyle!"

Home Buyer

"Carissa is professional and persistent on your behalf. She negotiated my impossible house purchase, cutting 40% off the original asking price! But more importantly, she patiently showed me so many properties that were great matches until I found THE ONE!! I’m so thrilled with my 100-year-old bungalow!"

Amy T.

"My recent experience in selling with the Maywright Property team was exceptional from beginning to end. Each member of the team, with whom I worked, was personable, knowledgable and responsive. They truly operate as a cohesive team, with each member performing at the highest level within her/his role. This reality allowed for my confidence and ease at each step of the transaction. Thank you, Natalie, Jess and Marg for ALL your assistance in selling my home. I appreciate you!"


Whether you are buying, selling or investing, it's important to have a team you can trust and depend on to guide you through the process. It's our privilege to assist you with your real estate needs. Contact us to learn more about our services, request a home evaluation or get an outlook on today's market!

Maywright Property Co.

Office hours by appointment.

*Please deliver all earnest money deposits to our Delaware St. location only. All checks can be dropped off in our secure lockbox to the left of the front door.

fill out the form to get in touch

Form Section 1
Enter your name.
Enter your email.
Value is missing
What's your message?
You must select at least one option
Enter your agent.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.