Natalie Clayton

CO-FOUNDER AND BROKER

License # RB16001824

Natalie Clayton is a Co-Founder and Broker / Realtor of Maywright Property Co., a fully women-owned real estate brokerage. You can find her serving local and relocation buyers and sellers in Downtown Indianapolis, Midtown Indy, Washington Township, Zionsville, Carmel, Westfield, Fishers and all of Central Indiana.

With hundreds of sales and a decade of experience in historic homes, new construction and luxury sales, Natalie is the expert and advocate you've been looking for. You'll appreciate her steady, methodical approach that translates to competitive wins for her clients.

Natalie loves spending time with her family - her husband Blake, their two sons, Len and Lou, and their two pups, Jack and Roe. They enjoy walking to their favorite coffee shop, visiting Indy's museums and parks and swimming and golfing at Woodstock Club.

Natalie brings to her work expertise, compassion and a commitment to empowering her clients. Since launching her real estate career, Natalie has been recognized as Rookie of the Year, an alumna of MIBOR's Real Estate Academy of Leadership, and a Bud Tucker Scholarship recipient, a scholarship aimed at those who show exemplary service to their community. She's also a member of prestigious groups including Hoosier Women Forward and the Stanley K. Lacy Leadership Series.

Natalie is an Indianapolis native and graduate of Indiana University, Indianapolis, where she studied public affairs and civic engagement as well as participated as a Sam H. Jones Community Service Scholar for four years. She has dedicated her career to knowing and serving Indianapolis and its people. Prior to entering real estate in 2017, Natalie spent a decade working in government and nonprofits, including serving as deputy director of the Greater Indianapolis Progress Committee under the Mayor's office where she worked on projects like the development of Eskenazi Hospital and Bank on Indy, a program that championed second chance bank accounts to reduce reliance on predatory check cashing entities and more. She has also held fundraising roles at National Future Farmers of America and the Indiana State Museum.

With more than 1,500 hours of service and volunteering, Natalie has spent time with organizations including the Athenaeum Foundation, where she currently serves as chair of the board of directors, with numerous neighborhood groups including the Fletcher Place Neighborhood Association, and other important nonprofits including Impact 100, Second Helpings, accessABILITY, Keep Indianapolis Beautiful, Indiana Landmarks, Habitat for Humanity and more. In 2016, Natalie and her husband also launched a $5,000/year scholarship program for students who have shown a commitment to community and public service. To date, more than $50,000 has been awarded to deserving students advancing their education.

Natalie would love to connect with you today!

Testimonials

"Natalie is an extremely intelligent, savvy and informed REALTOR^®. We had the pleasure of both buying and selling with her and she far exceeded expectations with both. My husband and I would like to specifically highlight her expertise surrounding the nuances of home inspections. She went above and beyond to protect us on our purchase; from guiding our questions, to knowledgeably evaluating a few issues and providing wonderful contractors to use. We have moved several times and cannot recommend Maywright more highly. Moving is stressful but Maywright managed to make us feel heard, taken care of and supported throughout every part of the process."

Elizabeth

"There’s no one more committed to her clients than Natalie Clayton and the Maywright Property team. As first-time home-buyers, we had so much anxiety about navigating the market and the home-buying process. We heard every horror story that to be competitive, buyers would have to offer thousands over asking, waive inspection and cover all closing costs. Month after month, we had put off setting up a search because we didn’t think we could forth a competitive offer. Enter Natalie Clayton. From our first meeting, Natalie equipped us with the tools, resources, and knowledge to make the best decision within our budget and means. She explained every step thoroughly and made sure that we felt confident with every part of the process. Natalie takes the time to truly listen to her clients and understand their priorities. We never felt pressured or rushed to make a decision. And in moments where we had uncertainty, Natalie would answer the phone (regardless of the time of day!) to provide counsel and peace of mind. In one month, Natalie took us from looking at homes to closing on the house of our dreams. She is fiercely loyal to her clients - advocating for their best interests every step of the way. Additionally, she works with a stellar team of vendors that mirror her high standards of customer service. We could go on and on about Natalie. In fact, we’ve lost count on the number of times we texted her: “Natalie, you are a boss”. Natalie cares so deeply about her clients - she is brilliant and incredibly knowledgeable of the real estate industry and the city of Indianapolis. Needless to say, if you work with Natalie, you will be in the best hands possible."

Katelyn

"Natalie was very highly recommended by family and friends, yet she still managed to exceed our expectations. As first-time homebuyers, we had a lot of questions throughout the process and Natalie was always there for us with quick, clear responses. She always made time for us to the extent that we felt like her only clients, though we knew that was not the case at all! She was patient with our needs and honest with her guidance while also encouraging us to make the decisions that worked best for us. Natalie and her team made the entire process so easy from start to finish, I don’t know how we would have managed without them. We are so grateful to Natalie and Maywright for everything and are LOVING our new home!"

Peter and Rachel

"Due to some unexpected circumstances, my husband and I needed to sell our home and move to a larger place on short notice. Natalie worked diligently and quickly to help us. We were able to purchase a new home, list our old home and be under contract with both homes within 7 days. Natalie was a great communicator, often reaching out to us to remind us about upcoming deadlines regarding the selling/buying of the homes. She was always available to answer my laundry list of questions and never missed an opportunity to offer her advice or guidance, which was more than welcomed. If you are looking for someone who will devote themselves 110% to you as a client, Natalie is the ONE! She loves her job and is extremely knowledgeable and passionate about her work. Selling our home was an emotional experience for us and she was extremely empathetic. She always went above and beyond throughout this process with us, and we are forever grateful for her."

Tracy and Cosmo

"Natalie and her team provided the most seamless experience in selling my home. All my questions were answered and concerns addressed quickly, so I could focus on my move and not on all of the behind-the-scenes processes and challenges that come with selling your home. From staging to closing, Natalie and team were there every step of the way, keeping me informed and calm (ha!) and ensuring I had everything I needed to understand tradeoffs and make decisions. I couldn’t have been happier with how it all worked out, and am delighted that my first home was in the best hands."

Amber

"We had the honor of working with Natalie in early 2020. She guided us through both the sale of our former home and the purchase of a new one. We are a family of four with four very different sets of needs and opinions. Natalie navigated our individual personalities and collective goals with a level of expertise and care that was incredibly impressive. Her command of market trends and sage advice made for a smooth sale and purchase - even amidst a global health pandemic! Natalie's level-headed yet compassionate approach to her work led us to our dream home. For that, we will be forever grateful."

Ryan and Andrea

LET'S TALK

Whether you are buying, selling or investing, it's important to have a team you can trust and depend on to guide you through the process. It's our privilege to assist you with your real estate needs. Contact us to learn more about our services, request a home evaluation or get an outlook on today's market!