Natalie Clayton


License # RB16001824

Natalie Clayton is a co-founder and broker of Maywright Property Co., a fully-woman-owned real estate brokerage serving clients and neighborhoods in central Indiana. As a top 1% agent in Indianapolis, Natalie brings to her work expertise, compassion, and a commitment to empowering her clients and brokers every step of the way.

In addition to her work at Maywright, Natalie owns 10+ real estate investments, including single-family, multi-family, and short-term rental. She believes in small business and is an investor in Milktooth, a nationally recognized restaurant in the Fletcher Place neighborhood. With more than 1,500 hours of service, Natalie founded Bourbon Women Indy, serves as vice president of the board at the Athenaeum Foundation, is president of the Community Heights Neighborhood Association, and is a member of Impact 100. In 2016, Natalie and her husband also launched a scholarship program for students who have shown a commitment to community and public service.

Natalie is an Indianapolis native and a graduate of IUPUI, and she has dedicated her career to knowing and serving this city and its people. Prior to entering real estate in 2017, Natalie spent a decade working in government and nonprofits, including serving as deputy director of the Greater Indianapolis Progress Committee under Mayor Ballard, where she worked on projects like Eskenazi Hospital, Bank on Indy and the Charles L. Whistler Award. She has also held roles at the National Future Farmers of America and the Indiana State Museum.

Since launching her real estate career, Natalie has been recognized as Rookie of the Year, an alumna of MIBOR’s Real Estate Academy of Leadership (Class of 2018-2019), and the Bud Tucker Scholarship recipient.

Natalie and her husband, Indiana State Representative Blake Johnson, reside in Indianapolis with their two dogs, Jack and Jamison.


Whether you are buying, selling or investing, it's important to have a team you can trust and depend on to guide you through the process. It's our privilege to assist you with your real estate needs. Contact us to learn more about our services, request a home evaluation or get an outlook on today's market!

Form Section 1
Enter your name.
Enter your email.
Value is missing
What's your message?
You must select at least one option
Enter your agent.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.