5357 Carrollton AVE Indianapolis, IN 46220 Active

UPDATED: 09/17/2025 06:36 PM ON MARKET: 14 days on market

Listed by Jenni Bliss McMillion • @properties

$450,000

3 Beds2 Baths3,184 SqFt

Key Details

Property Type Single Family Home

Sub Type Single Family Residence

Listing Status Active

Purchase Type For Sale

Square Footage 3,184 sqft

Price per Sqft $141

Subdivision Fred A Muellers

MLS Listing ID 22060325

Bedrooms 3

Full Baths 1

Half Baths 1

HOA Y/N No

Year Built 1925

Tax Year 2024

Lot Size 5,227 Sqft

Acres 0.12

Property Sub-Type Single Family Residence

Property Description

FOREST HILLS FAIRYTALE COTTAGE | Brimming with charm, this storybook home welcomes you with a quaint arched doorway and matching historic door. A cozy screened-in porch is the perfect spot for morning coffee. Step inside through the original levered windows onto top-nailed tiger-striped oak floors, accented by historic tile at the gas log fireplace. The light-filled dining room is wrapped in windows, and the central kitchen-accessed through a solid wood swinging door-features an eat-in peninsula, pantry cabinetry with slide-out drawers, a coffee bar, and stainless-steel appliances. The main level offers three generously sized bedrooms and a recently updated full bath. Upstairs, a versatile secondary living space serves as a family room and fourth bedroom, complete with mini-split system for year-round comfort. The unfinished basement provides ample storage and flexible space for a studio or office. Outside, immaculate landscaping frames the home, while a detached two-car garage sits at the end of a fully owned driveway. This incredible location offers convenience and walkability, with the option to purchase fully furnished-perfect as a turnkey Airbnb or an ideal move-in-ready home for a new owner.