neighborhood

Butler-Tarkington

Name: Maywright Property Co.
Address: 2509 N Delaware St., Indianapolis, IN, 46205
Telephone: (317) 210-0624

Tucked away behind the grand houses along the west side of Meridian Street and just a few miles north of downtown, is Butler-Tarkington. Named for Butler University and famous former resident, Hoosier author Booth Tarkington, this quiet neighborhood features an array of beautiful homes- think gorgeous Tudor’s and classic Colonials- and is known for its attractive residential architecture.

View The Market Report

Residents appreciate the way Butler University inhabits parts of the neighborhood, complete with all of the expected college life - Greek Row and college town shopping - yet doesn’t disturb the quiet of the area. The unique amenities and experiences Butler brings are truly one-of-a-kind. Holcomb Observatory and Planetarium, one of the largest public observatories in the world, houses Indiana’s largest telescope and offers fulldome star shows regularly. The arts are thriving at Butler, and Clowes Memorial Hall hosts a star-studded list of talent and personalities, including touring Broadway shows. Beautiful Holcomb Gardens is a 20-acre oasis of tranquility that overlooks a manmade lake, and Hinkle Fieldhouse, at one time the largest basketball arena in the country, is a National Historic Landmark and a thrilling place to enjoy Indiana’s favorite pastime.

Children and adults alike enjoy Tarkington Park for its playground, parkour-friendly spaces, basketball and tennis courts, and onsite cafe, an outpost of Indiana basketball legend Tamika Catching’s Tea’s Me Cafe. The yearly Sausage Fest at St. Thomas Aquinas is always hopping and features selections from the century-old neighborhood mainstay, Kincaid’s Meat Market.

You’ll love the full service deli at the Illinois St. Food Emporium, and their grab & go selection is perennially popular. Hoagies & Hops offers up authentic Philly-style sandwiches and cheesesteaks, and while you might go to Byrne’s Grilled Pizza for their namesake pies, don’t sleep on their award-winning cocktails. The Swiss-inspired, apres-ski vibe of Chalet makes it an eclectic stop for a quick breakfast of coffee and a bialy (the humble, yet very tasty, cousin of a bagel) and a quaint place to while away an evening over charcuterie and raclette. The rustic-chic atmosphere of Meridian Bar & Restaurant foreshadows the well-executed upscale comfort food they offer, and the view from the patio, of the historic homes along Meridian Street, is unparalleled, as is the coziness of tête-à-tête by the fireplace.

SEARCH AVAILABLE HOMES

Current Listings in Butler-Tarkington

Open 11/9 12PM-2PM

$350,000

3 Beds 2 Baths 2,488 SqFt

4260 Sunset AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Will Lonnemann of F.C. Tucker Company

Open 11/9 1PM-3PM

$384,000

2 Beds 2 Baths 2,742 SqFt

30 W 58th ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Anna Hassler of Maywright Property Co.

Open 11/9 3PM-5PM

$399,000

3 Beds 3 Baths 2,828 SqFt

322 W 47th ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Will Lonnemann of F.C. Tucker Company

Open 11/9 2PM-4PM

$886,500

4 Beds 4 Baths 3,348 SqFt

22 W 54th ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Brian Wayman of CENTURY 21 Scheetz

New

$1,195

2 Beds 1 Baths 1,776 SqFt

805 Berkley RD, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Pat Carmichael of Preferred Real Estate Services

4653 N Illinois ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

New

$428,900

3 Beds 2 Baths 2,714 SqFt

4653 N Illinois ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Elizabeth "Elly" Brown of United Real Estate Indpls

5301 Cornelius AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Pending

$395,000

3 Beds 2 Baths 2,101 SqFt

5301 Cornelius AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Andy Deemer of F.C. Tucker Company

3943 Graceland AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Active

$400,000

3 Beds 3 Baths 2,784 SqFt

3943 Graceland AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Troy Gaviola of Fathom Realty

4130 Rookwood AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Active

$219,900

2 Beds 2 Baths 1,752 SqFt

4130 Rookwood AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Gregory Randolph of Kevin Warren

Active

$1,250,000

4 Beds 4 Baths 3,700 SqFt

33 W 42nd ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Matt McLaughlin of F.C. Tucker Company

4902 N Capitol AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Active

$500,000

4 Beds 3 Baths 2,035 SqFt

4902 N Capitol AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Mallorie Wilson of The Real Estate Group

Active

$740,000

4 Beds 4 Baths 3,915 SqFt

134 W 44th ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Nathan Baurley of T&H Realty Services, Inc.

Pending

$475,000

3 Beds 3 Baths 2,994 SqFt

34 W 49th ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Nicholas McNeely of F.C. Tucker Company

Active

$185,000

3 Beds 4 Baths 4,040 SqFt

502 W 38th ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Cheryl Strode-Gregory of CC & R Realty, LLC

4619 Boulevard PL, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Pending

$699,900

5 Beds 4 Baths 3,118 SqFt

4619 Boulevard PL, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Bernard Goodman of Compass Indiana, LLC

5173 N Kenwood AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Pending

$599,900

3 Beds 3 Baths 3,331 SqFt

5173 N Kenwood AVE, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Eric Rasmussen of CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Pending

$400,000

2 Beds 3 Baths 2,646 SqFt

260 W 44th ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Brian Wayman of CENTURY 21 Scheetz

5301 Boulevard PL, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Pending

$474,900

3 Beds 2 Baths 3,084 SqFt

5301 Boulevard PL, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by GB Landrigan of GB Landrigan & Company

Active

$399,900

4 Beds 4 Baths 2,935 SqFt

440 W 40th ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Billy Ratthahao of Indy Dwell Real Estate

Active

$579,000

4 Beds 3 Baths 2,426 SqFt

654 W 54th ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Brigitte Dayan of F.C. Tucker Company

4651 N Illinois ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Active

$649,900

4 Beds 3 Baths 2,864 SqFt

4651 N Illinois ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Forde Ness of Berkshire Hathaway Home

302 W Hampton DR, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Active

$598,000

4 Beds 3 Baths 3,472 SqFt

302 W Hampton DR, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Sean Mullins of United Real Estate Indpls

Active

$265,000

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,992 SqFt

422 W 41st ST, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Gloria Gear of Keller Williams Indy Metro S

Active

$365,000

6 Beds 3 Baths 2,783 SqFt

714 Berkley RD, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Listed by Paige Corbett of Compass Indiana, LLC

Digital Millennium Copyright Act – DMCA Notice Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 11/10/2025. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

DMCA NOTICE

Maywright Property Co. strongly respects copyright protections. We will respond as promptly as possible to any reports of copyright infringement on our primary and supplemental websites, and in any IDX displays and IDX content. Maywright Property Co. works within the guidelines of the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act ("DMCA") to address and rectify any and all reports and instances of copyright infringement.

Infringement Reporting Procedure. To report copyright infringement, please email (preferred), fax, or mail all of the below required information, in written English, to Maywright Property Co. (our contact information follows):

i. Signature (hand-signed or electronic) of the owner, or a person authorized by the owner, of a copyright that is allegedly infringed.
ii. Identification of the original copyrighted work that is allegedly infringed, including website address / URL, location on the webpage, type of material (such as whether it is text, a photo, or both), a description of the work, and any other relevant information, sufficient for Maywright Property Co. to identify it.
iii. Identification of the material in an Maywright Property Co. website or display that is allegedly infringing upon the work from point ii. above, including website address / URL, location on the webpage, type of material (such as whether it is text, a photo, or both), a description of the work, and any other relevant information, sufficient for Maywright Property Co. to identify it.
iv. Statement that the complaining Party has a good faith belief that use of the material in the manner complained of is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law.
v. Contact information for the complaining Party, including email address, mailing address, and phone number.
vi. Statement that the information in the notification is accurate, and under penalty of perjury, that the complaining Party is authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed.

Copyright Agent Contact. Maywright Property Co.'s Copyright Agent contact information is as follows. Email is our preferred method of communication.

Maywright Property Co., Inc.

Attention: Maywright Property Co. DMCA/Copyright Designated Agent

(317) 210-0624

hello@maywright.com

Take-Down Procedure. Upon receipt and verification of notice of infringement, Maywright Property Co. will remove the infringing materials, at its sole discretion. To the extent possible, Maywright Property Co. will notify the infringing party in writing after removal. Advance notice of removal is generally not possible.

Termination for Repeat Infringement. Maywright Property Co. reserves the right to terminate access, for any or all of our Software and Services, to any Party, if that Party is found to be repeatedly infringing copyrights.

Last updated: 11/10/2025

Butler-Tarkington

Current Listings in Butler-Tarkington

Privacy Policy

1. Information We Collect

1.1. Information You Provide to Us

1.2. Information We Collect Automatically

1.3. Information from Third Parties

2. How We Use Your Information

3. How We Share Your Information

4. Your Rights Under CCPA

5. Data Retention

6. Data Security

7. Cookies and Tracking Technologies

8. Do Not Track

9. Third-Party Services

10. Text Messaging and FTC Compliance

11. International Data Transfers

12. User Rights and Control

13. Incident Response

14. Data Minimization and Accuracy

15. Children's Privacy

16. Email Communications and CAN-SPAM Act

17. Changes to This Privacy Policy

18. Contact Us

DMCA NOTICE